Best Pizza Near Me: 10 Hidden Gems You Need to Try
Are you tired of typing “best pizza near me” into your search bar, only to find the same chain restaurants popping up? Let’s face it – true pizza lovers know the best slices often hide in unexpected corners of the city.
Atlanta’s pizza scene has transformed dramatically since 2009, bringing a delicious mix of styles and flavors to satisfy every craving. From authentic Neapolitan spots using imported San Marzano tomatoes to creative fusion pizzerias crafting unique flavor combinations, the city’s hidden gems are waiting to be discovered.
You’re about to embark on a mouthwatering journey through 10 must-try pizzerias that locals cherish. Each spot brings something special to the table:
- Wood-fired crusts that achieve the perfect char
- House-made mozzarella that stretches for days
- Secret sauce recipes passed down through generations
- Innovative toppings that push culinary boundaries
These aren’t your typical pizza joints – they’re passion projects run by dedicated pizzaiolos who’ve mastered their craft. Some operate from cozy rooftops, others in historic buildings with stories as rich as their toppings.
Ready to discover your new favorite pizza spot? Let’s explore these local treasures that deserve a spot on your pizza bucket list.
1. Glide Pizza: Authentic New York-Style Pizza
Glide Pizza brings the taste of New York straight to your plate with their delicious sourdough crust pizza. Every bite will transport you to the bustling streets of Manhattan. What makes their crust special is the careful 48-hour fermentation process they use, resulting in a crust that’s light, crispy, and has just the right amount of chewiness.
Fresh Ingredients Made In-House
What sets Glide apart from other pizzerias is their commitment to using fresh ingredients made in-house. They make their mozzarella cheese every day, ensuring that each slice is topped with creamy, stretchy cheese that melts perfectly. The secret sauce, made from San Marzano tomatoes and aromatic herbs, adds a delightful sweetness and savory flavor to every bite.
Key Features That Make Their Pizza Stand Out
Here are some key features that make Glide Pizza’s offerings truly exceptional:
- Sourdough crust: Light and airy texture with a distinct tangy flavor
- House-made mozzarella: Freshly produced every day for maximum taste
- 48-hour fermentation: Develops complex flavors and achieves the ideal texture
- Artisanal sauces: Crafted in small batches to ensure consistent quality
The True NY-Style Experience
When you indulge in Glide’s pizzas, you’ll experience the true essence of New York-style pies. Each slice is thin enough to fold yet sturdy enough to maintain its shape. The bottom crust boasts a satisfying crackle when bitten into, thanks to its perfect charred finish, while the edges retain that coveted crispy-chewy texture loved by pizza enthusiasts.
2. Crispina and Firepit Pizza Tavern: Wood-Fired Excellence
You’ll discover authentic Italian craftsmanship at Crispina, where a Naples-trained chef creates masterpieces in a blazing wood-fired oven. Each pizza emerges with the perfect balance of char and chew, sporting that distinctive leopard-spotted crust that pizza enthusiasts crave.
At Firepit Pizza Tavern in Grant Park, award-winning chef Leslie Cohen (champion of “Cutthroat Kitchen”) brings creative flair to traditional wood-fired techniques. The signature spicy honey pizza has earned a dedicated following, while the unconventional “unicorn wings” offer a unique twist on classic Italian appetizers.
Both establishments shine with their distinct offerings:
Crispina’s Specialties:
- Traditional Neapolitan-style pizzas
- House-made pasta selections
- Authentic Italian cannolis
- Fresh-made panna cotta
Firepit’s Standout Features:
- Creative pizza combinations
- Specialty honey-drizzled crusts
- Craft beer selection
- Intimate tavern atmosphere
The wood-fired ovens at both locations reach temperatures of 900°F, creating pizzas with perfectly blistered crusts in under 90 seconds. These high temperatures lock in flavors while maintaining the delicate balance of crispy exterior and soft interior that characterizes authentic Italian pizza.
3. Nancy’s Pizza: Chicago Deep Dish Sensation
When you’re craving authentic Chicago-style deep dish pizza in Atlanta, Nancy’s Pizza is the place to go. This chain from Chicago brings the true taste of Windy City pizza right to your neighborhood.
What’s Inside Nancy’s Deep Dish Pizza?
Nancy’s deep dish pizzas are a work of art with their unique golden-brown crust that holds layers of top-quality ingredients. Here’s what makes it special:
- Bottom Layer: A buttery, flaky crust that keeps its shape
- Middle Layer: A generous blanket of melted mozzarella cheese
- Top Layer: Rich, chunky tomato sauce crowned with your chosen toppings
The Secret Behind the Flavor
The magic happens in their secret recipe – a special blend of cheeses that creates that signature stretch when you pull a slice. Their sauce strikes the perfect balance between sweetness and acidity, enhancing rather than overpowering the other flavors.
Classic and Creative Combinations
The menu features both traditional and innovative combinations. Don’t miss out on their bestseller, “The Classic Chicago,” packed with Italian sausage, mushrooms, and green peppers. If you like it spicy, go for the “Spicy Italian” which includes pepperoni, hot giardiniera, and fresh basil.
Patience Pays Off
Each pizza takes about 30 minutes to prepare – an indication of the love and care put into every deep dish creation. The wait may seem long but trust us, it’s worth every second as you’ll savor the gold standard of Chicago-style pizza right here in Atlanta.
4. Nina & Rafi: Detroit Style Indulgence
Located on Atlanta’s Beltline in O4W, Nina & Rafi serves authentic Detroit-style pizza. Their thick-crust pizzas have crispy, caramelized cheese edges and a light, airy interior that pizza lovers dream about.
Why Choose Nina & Rafi?
Here are some reasons why you should consider choosing Nina & Rafi for your next pizza outing:
- Thick and Crispy Pies: Enjoy square pies with perfectly crispy corners, a signature feature of Detroit-style pizza.
- Cheesy Bread Delight: Don’t miss out on their house-made cheesy bread, which is so delicious it could steal the spotlight from the main dish.
- Meatball Appetizers: Share hearty meatball appetizers with your friends or family for a satisfying start to your meal.
- Convenient Payment: Experience quick and hassle-free service with cashless transactions at the restaurant.
- Sunday Specials: Treat yourself to special Sunday deals where you can get round and Detroit-style pizzas for just $12 each.
The Art of Detroit-Style Pizza
At Nina & Rafi, the art of making Detroit-style pizza is taken seriously. Here’s what sets their pizzas apart:
- Distinctive Shape: Unlike traditional round pizzas, Detroit-style pizzas have a rectangular shape that allows for even baking and easy slicing.
- Wisconsin Brick Cheese: Generous amounts of Wisconsin brick cheese are used in every pie, creating an irresistible golden-brown crust that’s both crispy and chewy.
- Traditional Steel Pans: Each pizza is baked in traditional steel pans, which helps achieve that characteristic crispy texture on the bottom while keeping the center soft and chewy.
A Must-Visit Destination
Whether you’re a local or just visiting Atlanta, Nina & Rafi is a must-visit destination for pizza lovers. The combination of their prime location on the Beltline and exceptional pizza craftsmanship makes it an ideal spot for those seeking something beyond the traditional thin crust.
Join the Buzzing Energy
If you want to experience the buzzing energy of this restaurant, plan your visit during their Sunday specials when both round and Detroit-style pizzas are available at an affordable price of $12 each. It’s a perfect opportunity to gather with friends or family and indulge in delicious pizza without breaking the bank.
Nina & Rafi’s commitment to quality ingredients, unique flavors, and warm hospitality ensures that every visit is memorable. So why wait? Head over to Nina & Rafi today and treat yourself to a slice (or two) of their mouthwatering Detroit-style pizza!
5. Antico’s Authenticity from Naples
Step into Antico’s and you’ll discover the true essence of Neapolitan pizza craftsmanship. Owner Giovanni Di Palma brings his family’s treasured Pizza Napoletana recipe straight from the streets of Naples to your plate.
The magic happens in just 60 seconds – watch as your pizza transforms in the blazing hot oven, creating that perfect balance of crispy and chewy textures. Each pie showcases premium ingredients imported directly from Naples:
- San Marzano tomatoes for the perfect sauce base
- Fresh buffalo mozzarella with its signature creamy texture
- Extra virgin olive oil that adds rich, authentic flavor
- Fresh basil picked at peak freshness
The dough follows strict Neapolitan traditions, hand-kneaded and left to rise naturally. This creates the characteristic leopard-spotted crust with its distinctive charred bubbles.
You’ll find award-winning classics like the Margherita D.O.P. and the San Gennaro with sweet red peppers and cipollini onions. The restaurant’s dedication to authenticity has earned recognition from Italian pizza authorities and food critics alike.
The dining experience at Antico’s mirrors the casual, communal atmosphere of Naples pizzerias. The open kitchen layout lets you witness the artisanal pizza-making process while the aroma of fresh-baked pies fills the air.
6. Fellini’s and Argosy for Late-Night Cravings
If you’re a night owl looking for the best pizza places near you, look no further than Fellini’s and Argosy. These late-night spots serve up mouthwatering pizzas when most other restaurants have closed for the night.
Fellini’s: White Cheese Pizza Delight
At Fellini’s, the star of the menu is their signature white cheese pizza. It’s a delightful combination of ricotta, mozzarella, and parmesan cheeses on a perfectly crispy crust. What sets it apart is the ability to customize your pizza with a variety of fresh toppings:
- Fresh basil
- Roasted garlic
- Sun-dried tomatoes
- Italian sausage
- Caramelized onions
This level of customization is reminiscent of experiences at places like Blaze Pizza, where personalized pizzas are a highlight.
Argosy: Pushing Pizza Boundaries
On the other hand, Argosy in East Atlanta Village takes pizza to new heights with its innovative vegan options. They use a wood-fired oven to create pizzas with crispy edges and smoky flavors. Here’s what you can expect from their menu:
- Vegan chorizo pizza with plant-based cheese
- Impossible burger crumbles as a unique topping
- House-made vegan ranch drizzle
- Gluten-free crust options
Perfect for Late-Night Cravings
Both Fellini’s and Argosy keep their kitchens open well past midnight, making them ideal for late-night dining after events or when those unexpected pizza cravings hit. Whether you prefer the casual, no-frills atmosphere of Fellini’s or the craft beer bar setting of Argosy, you’ll find two distinct late-night pizza experiences to choose from.
7. Grana’s Rooftop Dining Experience
Located in the heart of Morningside/Lenox Park, Grana offers a breathtaking rooftop dining experience that takes your pizza adventure to new heights. With stunning views of the skyline as your backdrop, it’s the perfect setting for date nights or special occasions.
Wood-Fired Neapolitan Pies
Their wood-fired Neapolitan pizzas are cooked to perfection in authentic Italian ovens, resulting in crusts that are perfectly charred and toppings that are bubbling with flavor. The menu boasts a variety of both classic and innovative combinations:
- Signature Potato Pizza: A unique creation topped with thinly sliced potatoes, rosemary, and truffle oil
- House-Made Veal Meatballs: Served as a side or pizza topping, these tender meatballs are simmered in San Marzano tomato sauce
- Traditional Margherita: Made with imported Italian ingredients and fresh basil
Rooftop Ambiance
The indoor-outdoor rooftop space features:
- Comfortable lounge seating
- Heat lamps for cooler evenings
- Full-service bar with Italian wines
- Private dining areas for groups
The atmosphere strikes a perfect balance between upscale and casual, making it suitable for any occasion. You’ll receive attentive service that matches the quality of their artisanal pizzas, ensuring a memorable dining experience.
Commitment to Authenticity
Grana’s dedication to authentic Italian techniques is evident in every dish they serve. From their hand-stretched dough to their carefully curated toppings, each element is crafted with precision and care.
8. Karvela’s Buffalo Chicken Delights
Karvela’s Pizza has mastered the art of buffalo chicken pizza across multiple Georgia locations. Their signature buffalo chicken creation stands out with a perfect blend of spicy buffalo sauce, tender chicken pieces, and a generous coating of melted cheese.
You’ll find this pizza paradise in:
- Hogansville: The original location
- LaGrange: Their busiest spot
- Peachtree City: A local favorite
- Newnan: The newest addition
The buffalo chicken pizza features a hand-tossed crust that strikes the ideal balance between crispy and chewy. Each slice comes loaded with marinated chicken chunks tossed in their house-made buffalo sauce, creating a harmonious mix of heat and flavor.
What sets Karvela’s apart is their commitment to consistency across all locations. The buffalo sauce recipe remains a closely guarded secret, delivering that signature kick that keeps customers coming back. Their pizza pairs perfectly with their equally famous wings, available in the same distinctive buffalo sauce.
Pro tip: Ask for extra buffalo sauce on the side – it’s perfect for crust dipping. The kitchen staff will gladly accommodate special requests like extra cheese or different heat levels for your buffalo sauce.
9. Urban Pie for Colorful Gatherings
Urban Pie stands out as a social hub for pizza enthusiasts seeking a lively dining experience. The restaurant’s vibrant patio creates an inviting atmosphere that transforms casual dinners into memorable gatherings.
Signature Pizza Highlights:
- The Urban Classic – A perfect blend of fresh mozzarella and basil
- Spicy Mediterranean – Topped with feta, olives, and sun-dried tomatoes
- BBQ Chicken Supreme – House-made BBQ sauce with grilled chicken
The spacious outdoor setting accommodates groups of 15-20 people comfortably, making it ideal for:
- Birthday celebrations
- Team outings
- Family reunions
- Weekly game nights
You’ll find entertainment options adding extra flair to your dining experience:
- Live music on weekends
- Weekly bingo nights
- Seasonal poker tournaments
- Trivia competitions
The restaurant’s flexible seating arrangements and dedicated event staff help customize your gathering experience. Their group menu options include shareable appetizers and family-style pizza combinations designed for large parties.
Urban Pie’s commitment to creating a social atmosphere extends to their service style – pizzas arrive on elevated stands, encouraging sharing and conversation among guests. The string-lit patio setting creates an enchanting backdrop for your evening, while their indoor space offers a cozy alternative during inclement weather.
10. Lloyd’s Monthly Specialty Pizzas
Step into a time machine at Lloyd’s pizza parlor, where red-tinted chandeliers and wooden booths transport you straight back to the 1970s. This retro-inspired spot isn’t just about looks – it’s a pizza destination that keeps locals coming back with its rotating menu of creative monthly specials.
The star of the show? The Mark Buffalo – a flavor-packed creation featuring:
- Spicy buffalo chicken
- Crispy bacon pieces
- House-made ranch drizzle
- Melted mozzarella blend
Lloyd’s monthly specialty pizzas showcase the chef’s innovative spirit, transforming classic combinations into unexpected delights. You’ll find unique offerings like:
- The Potato Paradise: garlic mashed potatoes, crispy bacon, green onions
- The Mediterranean Dream: olive tapenade, feta, sun-dried tomatoes
- The Sweet Heat: honey-drizzled pepperoni, jalapeños, ricotta
Can’t decide what to order? The friendly staff guides you through the current month’s specials, helping you discover your next favorite pizza combination. Lloyd’s commitment to creativity makes it a must-visit spot for pizza enthusiasts looking to break away from traditional toppings.
Pro tip: Follow Lloyd’s social media to stay updated on their monthly specialty pizzas – these limited-time offerings often sell out quickly.
FAQs (Frequently Asked Questions)
What are some hidden gem pizzerias near me that offer unique pizza styles?
Discover hidden gems like Glide Pizza with its NY-style sourdough crusts, Crispina and Firepit Pizza Tavern’s authentic wood-fired Naples creations, and Nina & Rafi’s Detroit style thick crust pizzas that bring unique flavors to your local pizza scene.
Where can I find the best Chicago deep dish pizza near me?
Nancy’s Pizza is recognized as the gold standard for Chicago deep dish in Atlanta, offering perfect cheese-to-topping ratios that satisfy deep dish enthusiasts looking for the best pizza near them.
Which pizzerias offer authentic Neapolitan pizza using traditional recipes and ingredients?
Antico’s stands out for its Pizza Napoletana made from age-old Naples recipes and imported ingredients, cooked quickly in wood-fired ovens to deliver an authentic Neapolitan experience.
Are there pizzerias with special late-night options for pizza lovers?
Yes, Fellini’s offers delicious white cheese pizzas while Argosy features vegan chorizo and Impossible burger options, making both excellent choices for satisfying late-night pizza cravings near you.
What unique dining experiences do local pizzerias provide?
Grana offers a rooftop dining ambiance paired with wood-fired Neapolitan pies and distinctive menu items like veal meatballs and potato pizza, providing a memorable setting alongside great food.
How do monthly specialty pizzas enhance my local pizza options?
Lloyd’s Pizza Parlor features a retro vibe with monthly specialty pizzas such as the Mark Buffalo, combining buffalo chicken, bacon, and ranch flavors to keep your pizza experience exciting and fresh near you.
